Does Your Website Need a Redesign, a Rebuild, or Something Else?
Answer 15 questions in about three minutes and get a written diagnosis of where your website stands, with a printable report you can bring to your leadership team or board.
Built by Frances Naty Go, Website Systems Architect at Goldlilys Media, who has spent more than 15 years building websites and now works with museums, cultural institutions, nonprofits and mission-driven organizations.
How to Use This Checklist
Most website frustration starts with the wrong diagnosis. Some organizations commission a redesign when they need a rebuild. Others rebuild when targeted improvements would solve the real problem at a fraction of the cost.
A redesign updates the visual presentation and content of an existing site without replacing its underlying structure. A rebuild replaces the structure from the foundation: platform, navigation, and content systems.
The checklist looks at five areas: organizational fit, audience clarity, platform health, search and AI visibility, and ongoing care. If several people are involved in the decision, have each of them answer separately and compare results. Where your answers differ is useful information in itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a website redesign and a website rebuild?
A redesign updates the visual presentation and content of an existing website without replacing the underlying architecture. A rebuild replaces the entire structure from the foundation, including platform, architecture, navigation, and content systems, and builds a new site that serves the organization’s current needs.
A redesign is appropriate when the underlying structure is sound and the system is maintainable. A rebuild is warranted when the structure itself is the problem, when staff hesitate to make updates, when the platform is outdated, or when the site no longer reflects the organization as it exists today.
How do I know which one my organization needs?
Work through the five areas of this checklist with your internal team. Problems in organizational fit and technical health usually point to a rebuild, because they sit in the structure itself. Audience clarity problems can sometimes be solved with a redesign of navigation and key pages, depending on how sound the platform is.
If the problems are mainly visual or content-based and the platform is sound, a redesign may be enough. If you’re still uncertain after completing the checklist, the Executive Website Clarity Assessment provides an expert evaluation before you commit.
What does this checklist measure?
The checklist looks at five areas: organizational fit (whether the website reflects your organization today), audience clarity (whether key audiences find clear paths), platform health (whether the technical foundation is stable, accessible, and maintainable), search and AI visibility (whether people find you before they visit), and ongoing care (whether the website stays healthy and in your organization’s control between projects). Each area has three questions.
How do I know if our website still reflects our organization?
Ask three questions.
Does your website reflect your current programs, leadership, and priorities?
If a major donor, grant-maker, or board candidate visited today, would they come away with an accurate and compelling picture of your work?
Do your staff, leadership, and board feel comfortable sending the link to funders and partners without apology?
If most answers are no, the website describes an earlier version of your organization, and new content alone rarely closes that gap. This usually points toward a rebuild. If only one answer is no, updating specific pages and sections may be enough.
How do I know if our website is serving the right audiences?
Ask three questions.
Does your website give clear, separate paths for your key audiences, such as visitors, donors, members, and funders?
Is it immediately obvious how to give, join, buy tickets, or get involved?
Does the website use the language your audiences use, rather than internal terms?
If most answers are no, visitors may be arriving but leaving before they give, join, or get involved. Redesigning navigation and key pages can sometimes solve this, depending on how sound the platform is. If only one answer is no, clearer calls to action or a few restructured pages may be enough.
How do I know if our website platform needs to be replaced?
Ask three questions.
Is your website built on a current, supported platform that someone actively maintains?
Do your staff feel confident making content updates without worrying they will break something?
Does your website meet accessibility standards (WCAG 2.1 AA), such as keyboard navigation, color contrast, and alt text?
If most answers are no, new content and design would sit on an unstable base, and a rebuild on a stable, maintainable platform is usually warranted. If only one answer is no, targeted technical work is usually enough.
How do I know if people can find our organization through search and AI tools?
Ask three questions.
If you search Google for what you do, not your name, does your website appear on the first page?
If you ask ChatGPT or Perplexity to recommend organizations like yours in your area, does yours appear?
Do your key pages answer the questions your audiences commonly ask, such as with FAQs?
If most answers are no, the right audiences are not finding you. This is usually solved through content depth, FAQ structure, and technical signals on existing pages, not a new design. If only one answer is no, a few content additions and structural improvements to key pages can often close the gap.
How do I know if our website has the ongoing care it needs?
Ask three questions.
Is someone on your team responsible for website updates, with the access and confidence to make them?
Is your website covered by an active maintenance plan for updates, security, and backups, with a clear contact when something breaks?
Are your domain, hosting, and website accounts registered in your organization’s name, rather than a developer’s or a former staff member’s?
If most answers are no, the website will slowly decay however recently it was built, and fixed problems tend to return. If only one answer is no, closing that gap protects what you have already invested.
How are the checklist results scored?
Each answer that points to a gap counts as one point, and each “Not sure” counts as half a point. An area with no points is Healthy. Up to one and a half points is Needs attention. Two or more points is a Structural gap. The area with the largest gap, and how many areas have gaps, decide the recommended next step.
What does it mean if I answered “Not sure” to several questions?
“Not sure” answers are useful information in themselves. They often mean no one on the team has a clear view of how the website is performing. An objective assessment can answer those questions with evidence, so decisions are based on facts rather than assumptions.
What does it mean if my results show gaps in three or more areas?
Gaps in three or more areas are the most common pattern for established organizations whose websites have been in place for several years without structured care.
The right answer could be a redesign, a rebuild, or targeted fixes, and choosing too quickly is where most website regret begins.
An objective, written evaluation shows which gaps matter most and in what order to address them, before you commit budget or ask for board approval.
What if my platform is healthy but other areas show gaps?
A healthy platform suggests targeted work may resolve more than a full rebuild would. Focused updates to navigation, key pages, content, or search visibility can often address the gaps while keeping the investment you have already made. The exception is a structural gap in organizational fit, which usually points to a rebuild even on a sound platform.
What if platform health is one of my gaps?
When platform health is a structural gap, fixes to content or visibility would sit on an unstable foundation, so a rebuild becomes more likely. When it only needs attention, the platform issues are worth resolving before or alongside other changes, so new work does not sit on a weak foundation.
Why does ongoing care matter if my other areas also have gaps?
Without ongoing care in place, the other gaps are likely to return even after they are fixed. A documented care plan covering updates, security, backups, and account ownership protects whatever work comes next.
What if my results are healthy in every area?
Your website is in good health. Revisit the checklist once a year, ideally during annual planning or budgeting, so small issues are caught before they become expensive ones.
Can I use this checklist to support a grant application?
Yes. The five areas of this checklist align with the kind of technology needs assessment that capacity-building grant applications typically require. Documenting your answers, particularly the technical health, visibility, and maintenance sections, provides a structured picture of current gaps and the case for investment. The Executive Website Clarity Assessment report provides a more formal, third-party version of this documentation that can be attached directly to a grant application.
How often should an organization work through this checklist?
Once per year at minimum, ideally as part of an annual planning or budget process. Organizations that review their website health annually catch problems earlier, make smaller and less expensive corrections, and avoid the compounding technical debt that eventually requires a full rebuild. Organizations with active maintenance through the Sunlight Monthly Retainer receive ongoing monitoring that surfaces most technical health issues before they become visible to visitors.
What if our team disagrees about the answers?
Disagreement among internal stakeholders about website health is itself useful information. It usually signals that the website is serving some audiences or priorities better than others, and that the organization has not yet agreed on what the website’s primary purpose should be.
The Executive Website Clarity Assessment is particularly useful in this situation because it provides an objective, third-party picture that gives leadership a common starting point rather than competing internal opinions.
Is this checklist specific to nonprofits and museums?
The checklist is written specifically for museums, nonprofits, cultural institutions, healthcare organizations, and mission-driven organizations – audiences that serve multiple stakeholders simultaneously, operate in high-trust environments, and have governance structures that affect how website decisions are made.
The principles apply broadly to any organization, but the framing and the implications of each area are calibrated for mission-driven environments where credibility, accessibility, and long-term institutional trust carry more weight than conversion optimization.
Take This Into Your Next Leadership or Board Conversation
Website decisions are rarely made by one person. The printable version of this checklist is designed for your leadership team, board, or communications committee to complete together before a website decision begins.
Ask each person to answer separately, then compare. Where your team’s answers differ is useful information in itself.
Turn Your Results Into a Decision
The checklist shows where your website’s gaps are likely to be. Before you commit budget or ask your board for approval, it helps to confirm those gaps with an expert review.
The Executive Website Clarity Assessment gives you an objective, written evaluation of your website across all five areas, with a clear recommendation and the order in which to address what matters most. It’s the step between a checklist result and a confident decision.
If you’d rather talk through your results first, book a free 30-minute Website Clarity Snapshot. Bring your results, and we’ll start from there instead of from scratch.
