Skip to main content
Goldlilys Media Logo

Before Giving Tuesday: Test Your Donation Path From Search to Thank-You Page

To test your donation path before Giving Tuesday, follow the steps a donor takes: find the donate button, complete the form, and confirm that both the donor and your staff receive an email. Repeat the test on every device, and check that the form is accessible. Most problems are quick to fix once you find them.

Why check your donation path before December 1?

Giving Tuesday is December 1. For many organizations, it opens the busiest giving weeks of the year, and the website does much of the work.

Most teams spend these weeks on the message: the appeal letter, the social posts, the emails. Few check whether the path behind the message still works. A strong appeal that leads to a broken form loses a donor who was ready to give.

Donation paths also break quietly. A payment platform changes a setting. A page is renamed, and an old link stops working. A confirmation email starts going to spam. Nobody notices, because nobody on staff donates through the website.

A gift can be lost in two ways:

  • Before it happens. The donor stops partway, most often because the form asks for too much or the page does not say where the money goes.
  • After it happens. The gift goes through, but the donor never hears what it accomplished and does not give again.

Checking now gives your team two weeks to fix what you find. Waiting means finding problems through lost gifts.

What should your Donate page include?

Many problems are prevented by one well-built page. We recommend one Donate page, not several, so every donor arrives in the same place with the same information. Make sure it is the page that appears when someone searches for your organization’s name and “donate.”

Donors hesitate when they are not sure where their money goes. No one wants their hard-earned money to disappear. Your page should answer their questions before they ask:

  • What the gift supports: a specific program or cause, such as a youth art class or a new exhibition, rather than a general request
  • Where the money goes, and who it serves
  • When it makes a difference, such as a campaign deadline or a season of programs
  • Why it matters, in a sentence or two a donor can repeat to a friend
  • Terms and conditions, including your refund policy, recurring gift terms, and how donor information is used

Write in simple words your donors use themselves. This depends on knowing your audience: who your usual givers are, what they care about, and why they gave before. A page written for a foundation program officer reads differently from one written for a longtime member or a parent whose child attends your programs.

Three more choices make the page easy to use:

  1. Put the donate button in the top menu as its own button, separate from other menu items, so it is visible on every page. Never hide it inside a dropdown that takes several clicks to open.
  2. Embed the form directly on the page. A third-party donation platform is fine, as long as it offers an embed code. A form that matches your brand keeps donors on your website and connected to your story.
  3. Keep the form short. Too many required fields is the most common reason we see donors stop. Ask only for what you need to process the gift and thank the donor.

How do you test the path?

Once the page is ready, act like a donor. This is how we test donation paths for clients, and one staff member can do it without technical skills.

Use a real gift. When we test for clients, we make a real donation, often with the organization owner’s own credit card, and they can refund it afterward if they choose. A real gift is the only way to confirm that the form, the payment, and the emails all work together.

  1. Find the donate button. Start from your homepage and a few key pages. How many clicks or taps does it take to reach the form? Is the button easy to see?
  2. Review the form fields. Note every field a donor must complete. Is each one truly needed?
  3. Submit the gift and check both emails. A confirmation should reach the donor, and a notification should reach your staff. Check that both arrive in the inbox, not spam, with the correct details.
  4. Repeat on every device and browser. Test on a desktop, a phone, and a tablet, and in more than one browser, such as Chrome, Safari, and Firefox. A form that works on a large screen can be hard to use on a phone.
  5. Check accessibility. Try completing the form using only a keyboard. Check that every field has a clear label, that error messages explain what to fix, and that text is easy to read. Donors with disabilities should be able to give as easily as anyone else.

These accessibility checks follow recognized standards such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). They help you find barriers; they are not a legal review.

What should you fix first?

You will likely find more than one issue. With two weeks left, fix what stops a gift before what only slows it down.

Fix first: anything that prevents a donation. A broken link, a form that will not submit, a payment error, or a missing email. These lose gifts outright, and they are usually quick to correct.

Check your hosting. A busy giving day can bring more visitors at once than your website usually sees. If your hosting plan cannot handle the load, the site may slow to a crawl or show an error page, such as “Service Unavailable” or “Error establishing a database connection.” The gift is then lost to a technical problem, not a lack of interest. Many donors will not try again, because an error page tells them the site is not secure or stable. Ask your host or web team now whether your plan can handle a surge of donations on December 1.

Fix next: anything that adds doubt or friction. Extra form fields, a donate button that is hard to find on a phone, or a page that does not say where the money goes.

Save for January: larger changes. Moving to a new donation platform or redesigning the giving page adds risk in the weeks before your busiest giving period. Plan these changes for the new year, when there is time to test them properly.

Once your fixes are in place, run the test again. Then ask one person to check the path once more early on December 1, before most donors arrive.

What happens after the gift?

The donation path does not end with the payment. What happens next decides whether a first gift becomes a second one.

  • The confirmation email tells the donor the gift went through and serves as a record for their taxes. Without it, donors worry, call your office, or give twice.
  • The staff notification tells your team a gift has arrived. If it fails, the gift still goes through, but no one knows to thank the donor or record it.
  • A follow-up email about a month later tells donors which program their gift supported and what it helped accomplish. It shows them that they helped your organization reach one of its goals, and it gives them a reason to give again.

Set up the follow-up now, before the gifts arrive, so it goes out on time in January.

What should you do before December 1?

This week, a small team can do the most important work:

  1. Make sure there is one clear Donate page that names a specific program or cause
  2. Put the donate button in the top menu as its own button
  3. Make a real test gift on a phone and a computer, and confirm both emails arrive
  4. Ask your host whether your website can handle a surge of donations
  5. Fix anything that stops a gift, and save larger changes for January

A donation path is part of how donors decide whether to trust you. It deserves the same care as the appeal itself.

If the test raised bigger questions, such as whether your website supports donors well beyond one campaign, that is a decision worth making with a clear view of the whole site. Our Executive Website Clarity Assessment gives leaders an independent review of how the website serves donors, visitors, and funders, with a prioritized plan your team can act on in the new year.

For more on how funders judge your organization online, read What a Funder Sees When They Visit Your Website. If your confirmation emails are unreliable, The Email That Never Arrived explains why website emails fail and what to check.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do donors abandon online donation forms?

In our experience, the most common reason is a form with too many required fields. The second is uncertainty about where the money goes: donors hesitate when a page does not name a specific program or cause. Slow pages and unclear errors on a phone add to both. The simplest way to find your own reasons is to make a real gift yourself and note every moment you hesitate.

Where should the donate button go on our website?

Place it in the top menu as its own button, separate from the other menu items, so it is visible on every page. It should look like a button, not a plain text link. Avoid hiding it inside a dropdown menu, which adds clicks and makes some donors give up, especially on a phone.

Should the donation form be on our site or a third-party page?

Donors should complete the form on your own website. A third-party donation platform works well, as long as it provides an embed code that places the form directly on your page. The form should match your brand and keep donors connected to what their gift supports. Sending them to a separate website breaks that flow, and some will leave. If your platform sends donors elsewhere today, check whether it offers an embed code.

Can our website handle a surge of donations on Giving Tuesday?

It depends on your hosting plan. When many people visit at once, a website on a limited plan can slow down or show an error page. Donors who see an error often leave and do not return, because the site no longer feels secure or stable. Before December 1, ask your host or web team whether your plan can handle a surge in visitors, and whether it can be upgraded if needed.

What should we send donors after they give?

Send three messages. A confirmation email tells the donor the gift went through and serves as a record for their taxes. A staff notification tells your team to thank the donor and record the gift. About a month later, a follow-up email tells donors which program their gift supported and what it helped accomplish. That last email gives them a reason to give again.

fgo

Author Bio

Frances Naty Go is the founder and Website Systems Architect of Goldlilys Media, a San Diego web systems consultancy established in 2013. She builds website masterpieces for museums, cultural institutions, nonprofits & mission-driven organizations in healthcare and life sciences: structured sites that educate, earn trust, and stay easy for teams to update for years.

Frances has built websites professionally since 2010 and has supported the Balboa Park Online Collaborative’s web systems since 2015. A UC San Diego Computer Science graduate, she leads both strategy and build on every engagement, combining durable architecture, SEO, and AI visibility so the organizations she serves are found, understood, and trusted.

Categories: * *

Does Your Website Still Fit Where You're Headed?

A five-part checklist to help museums, nonprofits, and mission-driven organizations assess whether your website needs a redesign, a rebuild, or something else entirely.

Get the Website Redesign & Rebuild Checklist

A printable PDF of 15 questions across five areas (organizational fit, audience clarity, platform health, search and AI visibility, and ongoing care) for your leadership team, board, or communications committee to complete before a website decision begins.
By submitting this form you are subscribing to Masterpiece Website Muse, notes on web strategy for organizations doing work that matters.